单选题
PassageD
Simile,torefreshmemories,isafavoriterhetoricaldeviceofwritersthatcomparestwoessentiallyunlikethingsthatnonethelesshavesimilarcharacteristics.Thequarterbackwaslikealocomotive.Suigeneris,theLatinphrasemeaninguniqueoroneofakind,isahelpfulrestraintupontheformer.Somethings,eveniftheysharecertaincharacteristics,shouldn’tbecompared.Suigenerisisthebrakingsystemonarhetoricallocomotive,oratleastitshouldbe.Thatwasametaphor,bytheway,andnotaverygoodone.
Weinthenewsbusinesscouldstandtoapplythebrakestoourrunawayimpulseto“similize.”Ipersonallyloveagoodsimile,whichcaninjectlevityintoacolumn.Butlatelywe’veseeninstancesofsimile‐itisthatmighthavesavedreadersandviewerssomeangst,evenifwritersandpunditswereleftwithlesstosay.(Let’sgolightontheairhorns,please.)
Inthepastseveraldays,we’veheardnewspeopleandotherscompareObamacaretoHurricaneKatrinaandIraq.SarahPalincomparedournationaldebttoslavery.Countlesstimesinrecentyearswe’veseen“Nazi”appliedtopeoplewithwhosepoliciesorpoliticswedisagree,nonesofrequentlyasGeorgeW.Bush,thoughPresidentObama,too,hashadafewturns.
Alloftheaboveareclearlysuigenerisandshouldberetiredfromanyfuturesimilesunlesstheyarereferringtotrulylikethings,notjustasingleperson’simpressionoftheworldwhilemusingoncurrentevents.KatrinaislikeSandybecausetheywerebothnaturaldisasters,thoughsignificantlymorepeoplediedinKatrinathaninSandy.IraqissuigenerisandnothinglikeVietnam,towhichitwassometimescompared.
NazisandtheHolocaustshouldn’tbecomparedtoanythingelse.Thesystematic,state‐sponsoredexterminationof6millionJews,aswellasothers,issufficientlyhorrifictostandalone.Pro‐liferswhosometimescharacterizeabortionasaHolocaustareprobablynothelpingthecauseofrevelation.
Finally,slaverymeritsitsownplaceinAmerica’smemory.Tocompareittoanythingelse,especiallysomethingasmundaneasdebt,iswrongonitsface.IndenturedservitudetoChinamighthavebeenabetterchoiceforPalin,whoqualifiedherremarkwith,“Thisisn’tracist,but….”Note:Wheneveryoustartasentencewith“Thisisn’tracist,but...,”youprobablyshouldn’tfinishit.
InPalin’sdefense,sheobviouslymeantnooffense,andtheattacksinresponsehavebeensoviciousthattheattacksthemselvesarebeyondcomparison.OneinparticularwassoawfulthatIwon’trepeatit.JustasPalindidn’tdeservesuchanonslaught,peoplereadingthiscolumningoodfaithdon’tdeservetohavesuchwretchedthoughtsimposedontheirpsyches.
Theserecentexamplesofsimilesgoneawryraisetwoquestions:Whatistheimpulsethatdrivesourneedtomakesuchcomparisons?Andwhydowereactsoviscerallywhenwedo?
Theimpulseisusuallytoelucidate,i.e.,thisisasbadasthat.Butitisalsopartlylazy.DowereallyhavesolittleimaginationthatallwecandoissummonKatrinaeverytimeanadministrationfailstomeetourexpectations?OrHitlertodenoteourimpressionofbad?Surelyitisarhetoricalcrimetoturnsomeonesoevilintoacliche.
Fromapurelypoliticalperspective,theimpulsemaybedrivenbythedesiretoremindpeopleofthepasttransgressionsofpoliticalfoes.Thus,whencommentatorssayObamacareislikeKatrina,themindflitsfromBarackObamatoGeorgeW.Bushandonlythedifferences,ratherthanthesinglesimilarityofadministrativeincompetence,register:PeoplediedinKatrinaandPresidentObamaonlywantstohelppeople.Throughsubliminaljujitsu,therealcomparisonlandsinthecommunitypsyche.
Conversely,asSalonpoliticalwriterBrianBeutlersuggestedduringarecentconversation,evenRepublicansmayseebenefitstothiscomparisoninthatitneutralizestheongoing,negativeliabilityofKatrinafortheGOP.Butthenthecyclecontinuesintoabsurdity.IfObamacarecollapsesandRepublicanspresentAmericanswithRyancare,welikelycanexpectDemocratstocharacterizeeveryglitchastheGOP’sKatrinaII.
Tothemostimportantpoint,comparingahorrifictragedyoratrocitytoanyotherthingelsetrivializesanddiminishesit.Bytryingtocapture,quantifyandcategorizeothers’suffering,wetrespassonthesacred.
Somethingsarelikenothingelse—andshouldbelefttorestinpeace.
单选题
Accordingtothearticle,whichofthefollowingcomparisonsisreasonable?
单选题
Howdoyouunderstandtheword“Obamacare”inthisarticle?
单选题
Accordingtotheauthor,whichofthefollowingtermdoesnotbelongtosuigeneris?
单选题
Whatisthemainargumentorthegistofthisarticle?A.
单选题
Whichofthefollowingstatementsabout“suigeneris”iscorrect?
单选题
Accordingtothetext,whatisthereasonthatsomepeoplemakesomecomparisonswhichseemtobeinappropriatefortheauthor?