Bailey Watson, CFA manages 25 emerging market pension funds. He recently had the opportunity to buy 100,000 shares in a publicly listed company whose prospects are considered “above industry norm” by most analysts. The company’s shares rarely trade because most managers take a “buy and hold” strategy because of the company’s small free float. Before placing the order with his dealer, Watson allocated the shares to be purchased according to the weighted value of each of his clients’ portfolios. When it came time to execute the trades, the dealer was only able to purchase 50,000 shares. To prevent violating Standard III (B) Fair Dealing, it would be most appropriate for Watson to reallocate the 50,000 shares purchased by:
A is correct because Standard III (B) Fair Dealing requires members and candidates to deal fairly and objectively with all clients. Certain clients cannot be favored over other clients when their investment objectives and circumstances are similar. Therefore, the most appropriate way to handle the reallocation of an illiquid share is to reduce each client’s proportion on a pro rata, or weighted basis.