Girls Are as Competitive as Boys—Just more
Subtle
Girls are no less competitive than boys,
they simply employ more subtle tactics, a study of preschoolers suggests. While
boys use head-on aggression to get what they want, girls rely on the pain of
social exclusion.
To test the apparent differences in how very
young children compete, Joyce Benenson at Emmanuel College in Boston,
Massachusetts, and her colleagues divided 87 four-year-olds into same-sex groups
of three. In successive trials, each trio received either one, two or three
highly prized animal puppets.
The sexes behaved similarly when
there were two or three puppets to go around. The differences became clear,
though, when there was just one puppet for each group.
Boys
tended to ask for the puppet, grab at it, or even chase the child who had it. In
contrast, girls punished the puppet-holder by excluding her from their clique,
whispering behind her back or even hiding from her.
Avoiding Risks Benenson says that these
socially aggressive tactics may explain why girls exhibit greater jealousy over
same-sex friendships than boys. They could be trying to protect themselves
against exclusive coalitions.
Melissa Emery Thompson at the
University of New Mexico in Albuquerque, praises the study for creating "organic
yet controlled situations in which the children' s natural behaviour emerges
spontaneously".
She says the results help to dispel the myth
that females are the less competitive sex. Even at an early age, they avoid
risky direct aggression in favour of subtler forms of competition, such as small
shifts in tone and expression, or spreading turnouts.
Emery
Thompson says that these differences also explain why human males tend to
cooperate more effectively in groups while many females "work well in pairs and
tend to maintain only a few close relationships. "
QUESTIONS: