问答题 Explain why the sentence John saw a girl with a telescope is ambiguous, and explicate the ambiguity by drawing two or more syntactic trees for the sentence.

【正确答案】Ambiguity occurs when one expression has more than one meaning. There are two types of ambiguity: lexical ambiguity and structural ambiguity. Obviously the reason why the sentence John saw a girl with a telescope is that the sentence has an ambiguous structure. This sentence can be interpreted either as "John had a telescope and through it he saw a girl" ("with a telescope" telling how John saw a girl) or "John saw a girl who had a telescope on hersel" ("with a telescope" modifying "a girl").
The ambiguity can be solved by the following two tree diagrams:
(1)
(2)
【答案解析】[解析] 本题主要考查句法学的相关内容,尤其是树形图的画法。考生一方面要对句法学的一些基本概念非常熟悉,同时又要熟练掌握树形图的画法。做到了这些,本题也就不难了。