单选题 .  For years, the Tobacco Institute has tried unsuccessfully to refute (反驳) the charge by health experts that cigarette smoking can be dangerous to your health. Now the institute has taken a new tack (行动方针). In an advertising campaign last fall, the industry trade association ignored health questions and stressed that not smoking could be dangerous to the local economy. "Tobacco means $1,193,000,000 to Virginia," trumpeted one advertisement, "Virginia tobacco helps pave Virginia social programs. Tobacco means 90,000 Virginia jobs." The message was repeated with the appropriate dollar figures in six other tobacco states.
    The statistics are based on a study by the University of Pennsylvania's Wharton School, which calculates that, overall, the U. S. tobacco industry generates $30 million in wages and earnings, $15.5 billion in capital investment and $22 billion in tax revenue each year. "If you look at the economic contribution tobacco makes to America," says Edward Horrigan, Jr., Chairman of R. J Reynolds Tobacco Co., "there is no reason for us to be ashamed of the business we are in."
    The American Cancer Society disagrees. While Virginia is collecting its $1.2 billion in tobacco revenue this year, the Society said 2,900 of its citizens will be victims of lung cancer. Thousands more, the society could have added, will be victims of other diseases strongly associated with smoking. And the U. S. Surgeon General estimates the direct dollar costs of treating smoking-related illnesses nationally at more than $13 billion a year—not to mention another $25 billion in lost wages and productivity.1.  On what ground did the Tobacco Institute argue with health experts? ______
【正确答案】 D
【答案解析】 推理判断题
   文章第一段第三句中说到“...the industry trade association ignored health questions and stressed that not smoking could be dangerous to the local economy. ”再由下文的讲解和数据可知吸烟为美国经济作出了巨大贡献。A、B、C三项都不符合文意,只有D项较为符合。故选D。
[参考译文]
   多年来,烟草研究所一直徒劳地尝试着驳斥由健康专家所指控的吸烟会危害健康的说法。现在研究所已经采取了新的方针。在去年秋季的一次广告大赛中,工业贸易协会无视健康问题,着重强调了不吸烟可能会危及当地的经济发展。一个广告鼓吹:“吸烟对弗吉尼亚意味着1193000000美元。弗吉尼亚烟草有助于实施弗吉尼亚社会计划,烟草给弗吉尼亚州带来90000份工作”。这个信息在另外六个州里用适当的美元数字一再重复着。
   这个统计是基于宾夕法尼亚大学沃顿商学院的一项研究。该项研究估计,总体上说,每年美国的烟草行业创造着3000万美元的工资和收入,155亿美元的资本投资和220亿美元的税收收入。“如果你看到烟草给美国带来的经济贡献,我们就没有理由对我们所从事的行业感到羞隗”,雷诺兹烟草公司的主席爱德华说。
   美国癌症协会不同意。协会说,当弗吉尼亚州今年有12亿美元的烟草税收时,社会上就会有2900个公民将患上肺癌,可能还有数以千计的人会染上与吸烟有关的其他疾病。并且美国外科军医处处长估计,每年全国治疗和吸烟有关的疾病的直接花费要超过130亿美元,更不用说在工资和生产力方面所损失的另外250亿美元了。