摘要
虚假诉讼的关联犯罪具有多种类型,在诉讼欺诈的场合,否定构成诈骗罪的否定说不但遗漏了对不法事实的评价,而且其具体的论理也存在问题,应当坚持肯定说的方向,肯定诉讼欺诈成立诈骗罪;在诈骗罪的认定中,法院的生效判决是诈骗罪的处分行为,将财产性利益或者现实的财物作为处分对象会产生具体结论的不同,需要认真选择;在诉讼欺诈之外,虚假诉讼的关联犯罪还存在其他犯罪类型,理论上应当将其内容、范围明确化,并就相关疑难问题予以解决。
There are many types of relevant crimes in fraudulent lawsuit.In the case of litigation fraud,the negative theory of denying the crime of fraud not only omits the evaluation of illegal facts,but also has some problems in its specific theory.We should adhere to the direction of affirmative theory and affirm that litigation fraud constitutes the crime of fraud.In the determination of the crime of fraud,the effective judgment of the court is the act of disposition of the crime of fraud.Taking property interests or real property as the object of act of disposition will lead to different conclusions,should be seriously treat.In addition to litigation fraud,there are other types of relevant crimes in fraudulent lawsuit,which should be clarified in theory,and the relevant difficult problems should be solved.
出处
《清华法律评论》
2021年第1期199-218,共20页
Tsinghua Law Review
关键词
虚假诉讼
关联犯罪
诉讼欺诈
财产损失
充分评价
Fraudulent Lawsuit
Relevant Crimes
Litigation Fraud
Property Loss
Full Evaluation
