摘要
“诉源治理”的目的是提前并实质性化解矛盾纠纷,其蕴含着系统、依法、综合、源头治理的理念。民间信仰虽然不具备制度化、组织化的外在表现形式,但其本质还是一种具有内生性的社会秩序,这种自发秩序也可以作为治理资源的一种,进而成为“诉源治理”的渊源之一。我国的民间信仰虽然在现代社会有着巨大变迁,但是依然建立在本土文化网络基础上,民间信仰的广泛性、实践领域的公共性、社会参与的服务型、社区活动的道德性决定了民间信仰组织可以作为多元治理机制中的主体之一,进而成为诉源治理的“第三方”治理资源,民间信仰规则也同样可以被纳入司法裁判说理过程当中,使司法裁判说理内容更加符合事理逻辑。
“Governance of Litigation Source”is purported to resolve conflicts and disputes substantively in advance,therefore,it contains the notion of systematic,law-based,comprehensive and source management.Although folk beliefs do not take an externally manifested form of institutionalization and organization,they can essentially reinforce an endogenous social order,which would be a sort of governance resource,hence an effective means for settling litigations from sources.Although folk beliefs have made great changes in modern society,they are still embedded in the local cultural networks.The broadness of folk beliefs,the publicity of practices,the forms of participating social service,and the morality of community activities render folk belief organizations indispensable in multiple-agency governance as a major mechanism,and a“third party”for litigation source governance.Folk belief rules also can be incorporated into the process of judicial reasoning to make the content of judicial reasoning more logical.
作者
赵俊娟
ZHAO Jun-juan(Human Rights Institute,Southwest University of Political Science and Law,Chongqing 401120,China)
出处
《河北法学》
CSSCI
北大核心
2023年第2期184-200,共17页
Hebei Law Science
基金
2020年教育部重点研究基地项目“当代西方人权理论研究”(20JJD820007)的阶段性研究成果
2022年重庆市研究生科研创新项目“人权保障视阈下律师参与‘诉源治理’模式研究”(CYB22194)
关键词
“诉源治理”
民间信仰
异化
内生秩序
治理资源
司法裁判说理
“Governance of Litigation Source”
folk beliefs
alienation
endogenous order
governance resources
judicial reasoning
