摘要
公共政策作为一国法律秩序的安全阀,在商事仲裁司法审查中具有重要的制度价值。但公共政策作为一个开放性的弹性条款,其本身的内涵和外延并不具体、明确。中国法院在仲裁司法审查实践中对公共政策的内涵和外延不断进行探究与解释,而且对这一概念理解和适用也随着经济和社会的发展不断发展变化。本文通过分析商事仲裁司法审查实践特别是最高人民法院在这一领域适用公共政策的典型案件,研究公共政策概念不确定性中的相对确定成分,并就国际仲裁与国内仲裁司法审查实践中如何正确理解公共政策提出思考建议。
As a safety valve of a country’s legal order,public policy is of important system value in the judicial review of commercial arbitration.However,as an open and flexible term,the connotation and extension of public policy are not specific and clear.Chinese courts continue to explore and explain the connotation and extension of public policy in the practice of judicial review of commercial arbitration,and the understanding and application of this concept are constantly changing with the development of economy and society.By analyzing the judicial review practice of commercial arbitration,especially the typical cases of the Supreme People’s Court applying public policy in this field,this paper studies the relatively certain elements from the entire uncertainty of the concept of public policy,and puts forward some thoughts and suggestions on how to correctly understand public policy in the practice of judicial review of international or domestic commercial arbitration.
出处
《北京仲裁》
2022年第1期50-84,共35页
Beijing Arbitration Quarterly
关键词
仲裁司法审查
公共政策
递进识别
arbitration judicial review
public policy
progressive review
