期刊文献+

股权分置改革中的行政授予与补偿协商:公法与私法的融合 被引量:1

Regulatory Giving and Bargaining for Compensation in Stock Trading Rights Reform: The Convergence of Public and Private Law
原文传递
导出
摘要 中国的股权分置改革一方面要使非流通股股东取得流通权,另一方面也要让流通股股东获得合理补偿以求改革能够稳定推进。传统观点下的契约理论和行政征收理论均不能适切解释中国的股权分置改革方案。在公、私法融合背景下,美国学者新近提出的行政授予(regulatory givings)学说,可与大陆法上的行政行为附款理论相互协力,为股权分置改革方案提供正当性基础。应须指出,中国的改革方案通过非流通股股东和流通股股东协商的方式进行估价和实现补偿,采用财产法则而非补偿法则保障流通股股东的权益,实属符合经济效率之举。然而,本方案仍有诸多值得改进之处。 This article conducts a legal and economic analysis of the Chinese split share structure reform. Under the legal analysis, the authors argue that traditional approaches in private and public law fail to provide a valid legal or doctrinal basis for requiring non-tradable shareholders to compensate tradable shareholders for the right to trade. Even the more developed US regulatory takings jurisprudence would not provide the tradable shareholders with a right to compensation for the loss they suffered from the trading of non-tradable shares. This is where the authors turn to the new givings jurisprudence recently developed in the U. S. and apply the jurisprudence to the Chinese case - givings subject to a condition precedent. The authors then utilize economic analysis to evaluate the Chinese implemented reform and to propose some recommendations. In conclusion, the Chinese reform, has been a fruitful application of the givings jurisprudence. In particular, the innovation of u-sing privatized bargaining mechanism and the hybrid public-private nature of the whole process provide useful guidance on future government policies and regulations.
出处 《北大法律评论》 2007年第1期78-105,共28页 Peking University Law Review
关键词 股权分置改革 流通权 行政授予 补偿协商 财产法则 bargaining for compensation non-tradable shares property rule public-private law dichotomy regulatory giving split share structure stock trading rights reform
  • 相关文献

参考文献19

  • 1黄曼行.对国有股权不可流通性问题的探讨[J].商业研究,2005(12):171-174. 被引量:1
  • 2(美)约翰·亨利·梅利曼(JohnHenryMerryman)著,顾培东,禄正平.大陆法系[M]法律出版社,2004.
  • 3(美)理查德·A.波斯纳(RichardA.Posner)著,蒋兆康.法律的经济分析[M]中国大百科全书出版社,1997.
  • 4(美)伯尔曼(Berman,HaroldJ.)著,贺卫方等.法律与革命[M]中国大百科全书出版社,1993.
  • 5[罗马]查士丁尼,.法学总论[M]商务印书馆.
  • 6William I. Friedman.One Country, Two Systems; the Inherent Conflict Between China‘ s Communist Politics and Capitalist Securities MarketBrook J Int‘l L.
  • 7Abraham Bell,Gideon Parchomovsky.GivingsYale L J.
  • 8Guido Calabresi,A Douglas Melamed.Property Rules, Liability Rules, and Inalienability: One View of the CathedralHarvard Law Review,1972.
  • 9Madeline Morris.The Structure of EntitlementsCornell L Rev.
  • 10Carl J. Dahlman.The Problem of ExternalityJ L & Econ.

二级参考文献6

共引文献195

同被引文献10

引证文献1

二级引证文献3

相关作者

内容加载中请稍等...

相关机构

内容加载中请稍等...

相关主题

内容加载中请稍等...

浏览历史

内容加载中请稍等...
;
使用帮助 返回顶部