涨跌幅限制对证券市场影响的实验经济学研究被引量：8

Experimental Study on the Effectiveness of Price Limits on Security Markets

下载PDF

导出

摘要涨跌幅限制是一种稳定证券市场价格的制度安排。长期以来有关涨跌幅限制的政策效果一直存在较大的争议。本文借鉴西方实验经济学的基本方法,利用相关计算机实验系统,设置无涨跌幅限制、静态涨跌幅限制和动态涨跌幅限制三组不同的实验环境,分别选取实验参与人进行模拟证券交易,对静态和动态涨跌幅限制制度对市场的影响进行研究。本文得出的结论是,与没有价格限制的基准实验相比较,动态和静态涨跌幅限制都显著的抑制了价格对基础价值的偏离,提高了市场的信息反映程度。实验结果还表明,动态涨跌幅限制能够抚平市场反应的波动程度,提高市场的流动性,而静态涨跌幅限制在一定程度阻碍了交易的实现,影响了市场交易的持续性。 Price limits are used to attenuate overreaction and reduce excessive volatility in security markets. However, theories on the effectiveness of price limits are controversy. We design 3 sessions of experiments with no price limits, dynamic price limits and static price limits to study the effectiveness of price limits. Participants are involved in those experiments by a computer experimental system. Experimental results show, as compared with the experiments without price limits, both dynamic and static price limits can eliminate the price bubbles in the markets and improve the information efficiency significantly. In addition, dynamic price limits can attenuate the overreaction and underreaction. Dynamic price limits can also improve the liquidity in the markets, while static price limits block the continuity of trading.

作者杨晓兰

机构地区浙江大学经济学院

出处《南方经济》北大核心 2006年第10期5-16,共12页 South China Journal of Economics

关键词涨跌幅限制实验经济学证券市场 Price Limits Experimental Economics Security Markets

分类号 F830.91 [经济管理—金融学]

引文网络
相关文献

参考文献15

1胡朝霞.涨跌停机制对上海股市效率和波动的影响[J].厦门大学学报（哲学社会科学版）,2004,54(2):100-108. 被引量：17
2金雪军,杨晓兰.证券市场理性预期与泡沫的试验检验[J].世界经济文汇,2004(6):23-35. 被引量：3
3孙培源,施东晖.涨跌幅限制降低了股价波动吗?——来自中国股票市场的证据[J].证券市场导报,2001(11):12-17. 被引量：37
4吴林祥.《市场稳定制度对股价的影响及其改进-关于涨跌幅限制作用的实证研究》，深圳证券交易所研究报告．2002年.
5Anderson, R. W., 1984, The industrial organization of futures markets: A survey.
6Arak, M. and R. E. Cook, 1997, "Do daily price limits act as magnets? The caseof treasury bond futures, " Journal of Financial Services Research 12, 5-20.
7Bildik, Recep and Gulay, Guzhan, 2004, "Price Limits: How Effective? Evidence from the Istanbul Stock Exchange, "working paper, cited in http://ssrn.com/abstract=598922 .
8Friedman, Daniel, and Shyam Sunder, 1994,Experimental Methods: A Primer for Economists Cambridge, UK., and New York: Cambridge Universtiy Press.
9Forsythe R, Palfrey T, and Plott, Charles R., 1982, "Asset valuations in an experimental market," Econometrica, 50, 537-68.
10King, Ronald R.,Smith, Vernon L. ,Williams, Arlington W., and Van Boening, Mark, 1993, The Robustness of Bubbles and Crashes in Experimental Stock Markets, in R. H. Day and P.Chen, eds., Nonlinear Dynomics and Evolutionary Economics, New York: Oxford University Press, 183-200.

二级参考文献30

1蔡志明.经济学中的实验方法与技术——兼论实验经济学的发展[J].华东师范大学学报（哲学社会科学版）,1997,29(3):35-42. 被引量：15
2汪丁丁.实验经济学与中国经济学建设[J].经济学动态,1994(7):47-51. 被引量：8
3[1]LEE, SANG-BIN and CHUNG, JEE, SEOK. Price limits and stock market efficiency[J]. Journal of Business Finance and Accounting, 23(4), 1996.
4[2]KODRES, LAURA, E., Tests of unbiasedness in the foreign exchange futures markets: An examination of price limits and conditional heteroscedasticity[J].Journal of Business, 66,1993.
5[3]LEE, SANG-BIN and KIM, KEANG-JUNG. The effect of price limits on stock price volatility: Empirical evidence in Korea[J].Journal of Business Finance and Accounting, 22(2), 1995.
6[4]PHYLAKTIS, KATE and KAVUSSANOS, MANOLIS and MAMALIS, KIKAS. Price limits and stock market volatility in the Athens stock exchange[J]. European Financial Management, 5(1),1999.
7罗伯特·J·希勒.《非理性繁荣》[M].北京:中国人民大学出版社,2001..
8Friedman, Daniel, and Shyam Sunder, 1994,"Experimental Methods: A Primer for Economists," Cambridge, UK. , and New York: Cambridge Universtiy Press.
9Forsythe R, Palfrey T, and Plott, Charles R. , 1982, "Asset valuations in an experimental market, "Econometrica, 50, 537--68.
10Lei, Vivian, Charles Noussair and Charles Plott, 2002,"Asset Bubbles and Rationality: Additional Evidence From Capital Gains Tax Experiments," California Institute of Technology, Social Science working paper 1137.