摘要
《剿共随军日记》是一本历史当事人的记述。它虽有强烈的"反共"宣传性,但也记录了国共两党、两军不少"历史真实",如"剿共"粤军与国民党"中央军"的矛盾关系、共产党和红军的组织与军纪优于国民党和"剿共"粤军、"剿共"各军的宣传工作不如红军、"剿共"粤军的募夫制弊端丛生,等等。对待历史当事人的记述,应依据其记述历史的立场、动机和方法,采取冷静、清醒、理性的科学分析态度。
Diary of My Time with the CCP-Suppressing Army is a record made by someone who experienced history. Though the diary has a strong anti-Communist agenda, it indeed records many 'historical truths' about both the Guomindang and Communist Party and their armies. For example, he documents the opposition between the 'CCP-Suppressing' Guangdong Army and the Guomindang's 'Central Army'; the CCP and the Red Army's organizational and disciplinary superiority over the Guomindang and the Guangdong Army; the inferiority of the various 'CCP-Suppressing' armies' propaganda; the many abuses of the Guangdong Army's methods for recruiting porters; and so on. When faced with these kinds of record, we should make a calm, clear-headed, rational and scientific analysis according to the author's position, motives and methods for describing history.
出处
《近代史研究》
CSSCI
北大核心
2008年第3期24-43,共20页
Modern Chinese History Studies
