物文主义民法观的产生和影响被引量：7

The Come-into-being of the Property Law-oriented Theory of Civil Law and Its Influences

下载PDF

导出

摘要把物文主义的民法观的起源追溯到西塞罗时代,探讨西塞罗的市民法定义及其思想和经济基础,以及由此而来的政治态度,得出物文主义的民法观属于有产阶级的初步结论。以此为基础,继续探讨西塞罗的市民法观对于英语国家和大陆法系国家乃至社会主义国家的影响,结论是:物文主义的民法观具有追求公私法的明确界线的积极价值,但无产阶级国家对它的采用具有荒谬性。 This paper has cast back the origin of the property law-oriented theory of civil law to the Cicero＇ s time, by exploring the Cicero＇ s definition of jus civil and its ideological and economic foundation, and the Cicero＇ s political attitude decided by these elements, the author has arrived the preliminary conclusion that this theory of civil law belongs to the proprietary class. Furthermore, the paper has discussed the influences of Cicero＇ s theory of jus civil to the English-speaking countries, to the countries of continental juridical tradition, and to the socialist countries. The final conclusion is： the property law-oriented theory of civil law has some positive values because it seeks a definitive borderline between public law and private law, but it would be absurd if proletarian countries adopt it.

作者徐国栋

机构地区厦门大学法学院

出处《河北法学》 CSSCI 北大核心 2009年第1期60-64,共5页 Hebei Law Science

关键词物文主义西塞罗公私法划分人文主义 the property law-oriented theory of civil law Cicero division of public law and private law humanism

分类号 D913 [政治法律—民商法学] G12 [文化科学]

引文网络
相关文献

参考文献27

1徐国栋.再论民法中人格法的公法性——兼论物文主义的技术根源[J].法学,2007(4):3-15. 被引量：18
2Cfr. Cicerone, I Topici, Arnoldo Mondadori Editore, 1973,p. 203.
3Cfr. Giuliano Crifo, Per una lettura giuridica dei Topica, In Annali dell' Istituto Italiano per gli studi storici, I(196.7/1968) , Napoli, p. 140.
4[古罗马]西塞罗,王焕生译.论演说家[M].中国政法大学出版社,2003.189,133,145,303,333.
5Cfr. Cicero, De partltione oratio,100. On http://www. thelatinlibrary. com/eicero/partitione. shtml,2008年9月28日访问.
6Neal Wood, Cicero' s Social and Political Thoughts, University of California Press, Berkley, Los Angeles, Oxford, 1991, p. 105,127,107,106, 114,112,3.
7Voire Textes de droit romain,par Paul Frederic Girard et Felix Senn, Tome I, Dalloz, Paris, 1967, p. 557.
8[意]彭梵得.黄凤译.罗马法教科书[M].中国政法大学出版社,1992.斯奇巴尼的序言.
9[古罗马]撒路斯提乌斯.王以铸,崔妙因译.喀提林阴谋·朱古达战争[M].商务印书馆,1995.123,译者的说明第25页.
10H. J. Haskell, This was Cicero, Alfred A. Knopf,New York,1942, p. 199.