引文曲线的分析框架研究——以诺贝尔奖得主的引文曲线为例被引量：64

Citation Curves of Nobel Laureates

下载PDF

导出

摘要基于341位诺贝尔物理学、化学、生理学或医学、经济学奖获得者的引文曲线,借助曲线拟合方法构建引文曲线的分析框架,包括两种规则引文曲线——经典引文曲线、指数增长引文曲线,和三种不规则引文曲线——睡美人引文曲线、双峰引文曲线、波型引文曲线。以诺贝尔奖得主为例的实证分析表明:①引文曲线的分析框架是一种新的引文分析视角;②引文曲线的分析框架可用于将一组(有一定影响力的)论文或作者划分层次,也可用于分析不同学科论文或作者的引用差异。文章最后分析了该框架的适用性。图4。表1。参考文献32。 Applying curve fitting and sign test, this paper constructs a framework of citation curves based on citation curves of 341 Nobel laureates in the fields of physics, chemistry＇, physiology or medicine and economics. The framework involves lognor- mal and exponential curves as regular curves, and sleeping-beauty, double-peaks and wave-form as irregular ones. The empirical analysis shows that the framework, as a new perspective to citation analysis, can be used to group influential papers or authors, and to analyze the differences of citation behaviors in different disciplines. 4 figs. 1 tab. 32 refs.

作者李江姜明利李玥婷

机构地区浙江大学信息资源管理系

出处《中国图书馆学报》 CSSCI 北大核心 2014年第2期41-49,共9页 Journal of Library Science in China

基金国家自然科学基金项目"跨学科知识扩散的规律研究(编号:71203193)"的研究成果之一

关键词引文曲线诺贝尔奖对数正态睡美人分析框架 Citation curve. Nobel Prize. Lognormal function. Sleeping-beauty. Analysis framework.

分类号 G354.2 [文化科学—情报学]

引文网络
相关文献

参考文献31

1Garfield E.More delayed recognition.Part 1.Examples from the genetics of color blindness,the entropy of short-term memory,phosphoinositides,and polymer Rheology[J].Current Contents,1989,38:3-8.
2Aversa E S.Citation patterns of highly cited papers and their relationship to literature aging:A study of the working literature[J].Scientometrics,1985,7(3-6):383-389.
3Redner S.Citation statistics for more than a century of physical review[J].Physics Today,2004,58(6):49-54.
4Cano V,Lind N C.Citation life cycles of ten citation classics[J].Scientometrics,1991,22(2):297-312.
5Cunningham S J.An empirical investigation of the obsolescence rate for information systems literamre[J/OL].Library and Information Science Research.1995[2012-07-20].http://library.fgcu.edu/iclc/lisrissu.htm.
6Nakamoto H.Synchronous and dyachronous citation distributions[G] //Egghe L,Rousseau R.Informetrics 87/88.Amsterdam:Elsevier Science Publishers,1988:157-163.
7Line M B,Sandison A."Obsolescence" and changes in the use of literature with tme[J].Journal of Documentation,1974,30(3):283-350.
8Griffith B C,Scrvi P N,Anker A,et al.The aging of scientific literature:A citation analysis[J].Journal of Documentation,1979,35(3):179-196.
9Stinson E R,Lancaster F W.Synchronous versus diachronous methods in the measurement of obsolescence by citation studies[J].Joumal of Information Science,1987,13(2):65-74.
10Gupta U.Obsolescence of physics litemture:Exponential decrease of the density of citatiom to physical review articles with age[J].Journal of the American Society for Information Science,1990,41(4):282-287.

二级参考文献6

1Van Raan A E J. Advanced bibliometric methods as quantitative core of peer review based evaluation and foresight exercises. Scientometrics, 1996, 36 (6) : 397 -420.
2Glanzel W. Seven myths in bibkiometrics: About facts and fiction in quantitative science studies. Proceedings of WIS 2008, http://www. collnet. de/Berlin-2008/.
3Hirsch J E. An index to quantify an individual's scientific research output. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the USA, 2005, 102(46) : 16569 - 16572.
4Lehmann S, et al. Measures for measures. Nature, 2006, 444(7122) : 1003 - 1004.
5Doring T F. Quality evaluation needs some better quality tools. Nature, 2007, 445 (7129 ) : 709.
6Garwin L, Lincoln T. A century of nature: Twenty-One discoveries that changed science and the world. University of Chicago Press, 2003.