SCI和影响因子:学术评估与商业运作——Nature实证研究之三被引量：12

SCI and Journal Impact Factor:Academy Evaluation and Commercial Operations——An Empirical Study of Nature(3)

下载PDF

导出

摘要 SCI论文(引用)及期刊"影响因子",被当今学界视为最权威的学术评估手段,却严重忽视了这两者纯粹的商业性质。本文集中考察三个方面内容:SCI论文(引用)和期刊"影响因子"的历史形成过程;上述两者规则设计的合理性质疑;揭示两者背后的商业化运作机制及学术包装手法。 SCI and journal impact factor are used as authoritative instruments to evaluate academic works. This paper focuses on the forming process of SCI and journal impact factor, the criticism of their rules, and the revelation of their commercial operations and academic packing tricks.

作者穆蕴秋江晓原

机构地区上海交通大学科学史与科学文化研究院

出处《上海交通大学学报（哲学社会科学版）》 CSSCI 北大核心 2015年第5期68-80,共13页 Journal of Shanghai Jiao tong University(Philosophy and Social Sciences)

关键词 SCI(科学引用索引) JCR(期刊引证报告) 影响因子尤金·加菲尔德 SCI （Science Citation Index） JCR （Journal Citation Report） impact factor Eugene Garfield

分类号 G353.1 [文化科学—情报学]

引文网络
相关文献

参考文献50

1I. Fuyuno &- D. Cyranoski. Cash for papers: putting a premium on publication[J]. Nature. 2006,441:792.
2E. Garfield. How it all begain-with a loan from HFC. Current Contents. 1980-01-21. 3..5-8.
3W.C. Adair. Citation Indexes for Scientific Literature. American Documentation. 1955.6:31-32.
4E. Garfield. How can impact factors be improved. British Medical Journal. 1996. 313:411-3.
5E. Garfield. Science citation index. Science. 1955;122:108- 110.
6P. L. K. Gross, E. M. Gross. College libraries and chemical education. Seienee, 1927, 66 (1713): 385-389.
7P. L. K. Gross, A. O. Woodford. Serial literature used by American geologists. Science, 1931,73 (1903) 660-664.
8I. Haekh. The periodicals useful in the dental library. Bull Med Libr Assoc. 1936, 25 (1-2): 109-112.
9Trie Arehambault, Vincent Lariviere. History of the journal impact factor: contingencies and consequences[J]. Seientometrics. 2009. 79: 635-649.
10E. Garfield. Of Nobel Class' : Part 1. An Overview of1S1 Studies on Highly Cited Authors and Nobel Laureates[J]. Current Contents. 1992-0815:116-126.

同被引文献76

1徐晓泉,毛文明,郑俊海,瞿佳.我国眼科类学术期刊主要计量指标统计与分析[J].中国科技期刊研究,2008,19(3):391-393. 被引量：6
2任鸿隽.中国科学社社史简述[J].中国科技史杂志,1983,18(1):2-13. 被引量：45
3郭碧坚,韩宇.同行评议制──方法、理论、功能、指标[J].科学学研究,1994,12(3):63-73. 被引量：80
4翁奕波.论学术期刊的准商品属性[J].中国科技期刊研究,2005,16(5):595-598. 被引量：14
5http://www.nature.com/nature/authors/gta/index.html#a1.1.
6Chew M,Villanueva EV,Van Der Weyden M B.Life and times of the impact factor:retrospective analysis of trends for seven medical journals(1994-2005)and their Editors'views[J].Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine.2007.100(3):142-50.
7Kathleen D.Hopkins,Laragh Gollogly,Sarah Ogden&Richard Horton.Strange results mean it's worth checking ISI data[J].Nature.2002-02-14.415:732.
8E.Garfield.Nature:112Years of Continuous Publication of High Impact Research and Science Journalism[J].Current Contents.1981-10-05.40:5-12.
9E.Garfield.Science:101Years of Publication of High Impact Science Journal[J].Current Contents.1981-09-28.39:253-259.
10The impact factor game[J].Plos Medicine.2006-06.3(6):707-709.