摘要
悖论的矛盾归属问题一直被众多学者争论不休,悖论矛盾到底属于逻辑矛盾,还是属于辩证矛盾,或者同时属于逻辑矛盾与辩证矛盾,还是除了逻辑矛盾和辩证矛盾以外的第三类矛盾。在这个问题上,香港著名逻辑学家黄展骥认为悖论矛盾毫无疑问属于逻辑矛盾,并且是一种特殊的逻辑矛盾,但是在黄展骥看来,逻辑矛盾和辩证矛盾并不是决然对立的,辩证法指出了形式逻辑中的"矛盾律"存在原则上的缺陷,但是在某些方面走向了极端,必须给予技术上的弥补,黄展骥的做法是设置"含混区",从"二分法"走向"三分法",这样就化解了逻辑矛盾和辩证矛盾的紧张冲突,修补了形式逻辑中的"矛盾律"的固有缺陷。
Paradox contradiction attribute has been debated by many scholars.The question is whether paradox contradiction belongs to logic contradiction or dialectical contradiction,or belongs to logical contradiction and dialectical contradiction at the same time,or the third kind of contradiction in addition to logical contradiction and dialectical contradiction.For this issue,Huang Zhan-ji,the famous logician from Hong Kong,thinks paradox contradiction no doubt belongs to the logical contradiction,and is a special kind of logical contradiction.However,Huang Zhan-ji believes that logical contradiction and dialectical contradiction are not utterly polarized.Dialectics points out that there are principle defects in the＂law of contradiction＂in the formal logic,but in some ways to the extreme.So it must be revised.By setting the＂vague area＂,from ＂dichotomy＂to ＂trichotomy＂,Huang Zhan-ji dissolves the trained conflict between logical contradiction and dialectical contradiction and repairs the inherent defects of＂law of contradiction＂in the formal logic.
出处
《河北广播电视大学学报》
2017年第3期74-78,共5页
Journal of Hebei Radio & TV University
关键词
逻辑矛盾
辩证矛盾
矛盾律
含混区
三分法
logical contradiction
dialectical contradiction
law of contradiction
vague area
trichotomy
