摘要
随着Altmetrics的诞生和热议,本文从数据来源,计量指标,评价时效三方面对Altmetrics与传统科研评价方法进行了对比分析。发现Altmetric具有数据来源更广泛,评价指标更全面,更高效的优势。同时,分析了Altmetrics在语言选择、数据采集和有效性、标准统一上存在的问题。得出了Altmetrics在短期内不能取代传统科研评价方法的结论.
With the birth and heated debate of Altmetrics, this paper compares Altmetrics with traditional scientific evaluation methods from three aspectsls： data source, caculating index and evaluation effect. It is found that Altmetric has a more comprehensive and efficient source of data. At the same time, it analyzes the problems of Altmetrics in language selection, data acquisition and validity, and standard unification. It concluded that Altmetrics can not re- place the traditional scientific evaluation method in the short term.
作者
刘焕成
胡雨薇
李素巧
LIU Huancheng, HU Yuwei,LI Suqiao(Information Science Department, Zhengzhou University of Aeronautics, Henan Zhengzhou 450046, Chin)
出处
《评价与管理》
2017年第3期9-12,共4页
Evaluation & Management
