摘要
行政简易程序选择权是行政案件繁简分流改革中的重要理论问题。从性质上看,行政简易程序选择权是诉权的延伸和审判权的下放。从诉讼经济原则的角度上看,法官主导简易程序选择权更具有成本优势。行政简易程序选择权背后隐藏的个体正义与社会正义的冲突值得关注。在个体正义迈向社会正义存在逻辑缺陷和路径障碍的情况下,通过社会正义的分配实现个体正义和社会正义的融合不失为可行之举,而《行政诉讼法》应当对简易程序的价值嬗变作出回应,通过适当扩大简易程序的适用范围和简化简易程序的审理程序,从而达成行政简易程序公正与效率的统一。
The option of administrative sample procedure is an important theoretical issue in the reform of separating complicated and simple administrative cases.In nature,the option of administrative sample procedure is the extension of the right of action and the devolution of judicial power.From the perspective of the economic principle of litigation,it is more cost-effective for the judge to lead the choice of sample procedure.The conflict between individual justice and social justice behind the choice right of administrative sample procedure deserves our attention.In the case of logic defects and path obstacles in the process of individual justice moving towards social justice,it is feasible to realize the integration of individual justice and social justice through the distribution of social justice.The Administrative Procedure Law should respond to the evolution of the value of sample procedure,and achieve the unity of justice and efficiency of the summary procedure of administrative procedure by properly expanding the scope of application of the summary procedure and simplifying the trial procedure of the summary procedure.
作者
黄锡生
王中政
HUANG Xi-sheng;WANG Zhong-zheng(School of Law,Chongqing University,Chongqing 400044,China)
出处
《内蒙古社会科学》
CSSCI
北大核心
2020年第5期80-88,F0002,共10页
Inner Mongolia Social Sciences
基金
最高人民法院2019年度司法研究重大课题“行政案件繁简分流改革研究”(编号:ZGYFZDKT201911-01)
国家社科基金重大项目“生态文明法律制度建设研究”(编号:14ZDC029)。
关键词
行政诉讼
简易程序
选择权
社会正义
程序分流
Administrative Litigation
Simple Procedure
Option
Social Justice
Procedure Division
