摘要
关于论文篇幅与被引频次的关系,业界倾向认为其呈正相关关系,近年来图书馆情报与文献学期刊载文量急剧下降或许与之相关,有必要重新进行剖析。文章以《图书情报工作》期刊为研究对象,基于中国知网数据库,综合采用独立样本t检验、回归分析、分位数回归研究了论文篇幅与被引频次的关系。研究结果表明:长篇幅论文平均被引频次并不占有优势;论文篇幅与被引频次总体上无关,也不存在非线性关系;增加论文篇幅可以提高低被引频次论文的被引次数;增加论文篇幅进而提高影响因子的机制是降低分母载文量,并非提高论文影响力。根据以上研究结果,文章指出,近年来图书馆情报与文献学期刊载文量持续下降的现象有必要进行修正,学术期刊应以论文质量为主,不宜简单增加论文篇幅控制载文量。
Regarding the relationship between the length of papers and the citation frequency,most of the academic circles believe that there is a positive correlation,which leads to a sharp decline in the number of papers carried in library information and philology journals in recent years,so it is necessary to re-analyze it.Based on CNKI citation database,this paper takes Library and Information Work as the research object and comprehensively uses the independent samples t-test,regression analysis,quantile regression to study the relationship between the length of papers and the citation frequency.The results show that the average citation frequency in the middle and low-length papers is higher;the length of papers is not related to the citation frequency as a whole,nor does it have a non-linear relationship;increasing the length of papers can improve the citation frequency of low-cited papers.According to the above research results,this paper points out that in recent years,the phenomenon of continuous decline in the number of articles in library information and philology journals needs to be revised.Academic journals should mainly focus on the quality of papers,and it is not appropriate to simply increase the length of papers to control article quantity.
出处
《情报理论与实践》
CSSCI
北大核心
2020年第10期50-54,共5页
Information Studies:Theory & Application
基金
国家社会科学基金项目“学术评价与创新绩效评价问题研究”(项目编号:19FTQB011)
浙江省一流学科A类项目(浙江工商大学统计学,管理科学与工程)的研究成果。
关键词
学术论文
论文篇幅
高被引论文
被引频次
载文量
期刊影响力
academic paper
length of papers
high-cited papers
citation frequency
article quantity
journal influence
