摘要
在没有明确的惩罚性法律后果的情形下,集体土地征收行为更易脱离法定程序轨道,给征收补偿安置结果的公正公平带来极大的不确定性。通过总结提炼司法实践中的征收程序违法类型,并结合新修正的《土地管理法》及其《实施条例草案》的规定,分析后得出,只有通过立法来设置必要的惩罚性后果条款,在司法审查过程中坚持结果和行为完整性并行的裁判标准,方可避免权利人的程序性权利遭到侵害,进而确保征收补偿安置的实体正义之车“轮”在征收程序正义之“轨”上合法运行而抵达公平公正的终点。
Without the absence of clear punitive legal consequences,the procedural violations of Collectively-owned Land expropriation tends to bring great uncertainty to the justice and fairness of expropriation and compensation.For this,The newly amended Land Administration Law and Regulation on the Implementation of the Land Administration Law do not provide clear regulation.In view of the type of procedural violation,only to set necessary punitive consequences clauses by legislation,and adhere to the parallel examination standards of result and integrity of conduct by judicial judgment,can we ensure that the substantive justice of the expropriation and compensation to achieve under the security of the expropriation procedure.
作者
张启江
ZHANG Qi-jiang(Law School of the Hunan Normal University, Changsha, Hunan 410081, China)
出处
《时代法学》
2020年第5期53-64,共12页
Presentday Law Science
基金
湖南省社科规划办项目“集体土地征收案件司法审查问题研究(编号19YBA224)”的成果。
关键词
集体土地
土地征收
程序违法
法律后果
Collectively-owned Land
land expropriation
procedural violation
legal consequence
