摘要
当代中国刑法解释学必须尽快实现由原初的功能主义转向结果与方法并重整全论的功能主义的范式转型,以结果与方法并重整全论、刑法解释方法确证功能体系化、刑法解释结论有效性整体主义、司法公正相对主义为重要创新维度,真正构建起具有中国本土化特色的功能主义刑法解释学理论体系,为切实解决中国问题提出中国方案;必须以“宏观同质、微观互补”的刑法教义学与刑法解释学关系论为基础维持刑法解释学的学科独立性,强化刑法解释学的方法论特色,在刑法解释学中要有意识地吸纳刑法教义学原理并促进刑法解释学教义化,从而更进一步充实刑法解释学的理论包容性和诠释有效性,同时在刑法教义学中要有意识地吸纳刑法解释学原理以进一步增强刑法教义学的诠释学方法论内容和动态阐释力。
Contemporary China’s Criminal Law Hermeneutics must realize the paradigm transformation from the original functionalism to the result and method and reorganize the whole theory of functionalism as soon as possible,taking the typology and systematization of criminal law interpretation methods,the holism of validity of interpretation conclusion,the purposefulness of criminal policies,the overall effectiveness and the relativism of judicial justice as important innovation dimensions,and taking“macro homogeneity based on the theory of the relationship between micro complementary criminal law doctrine and Criminal Law Hermeneutics”to maintain the discipline independence of Criminal Law Hermeneutics and strengthening the methodological characteristics of Criminal Law Hermeneutics.Criminal Law Hermeneutics should consciously absorb the theory of criminal law doctrine,and promote its doctrine to enrich the theoretical inclusiveness and effectiveness of Criminal Law Hermeneutics.Criminal law doctrine should consciously absorb the theory of Criminal Law Hermeneutics at the same time to further enhance the contents of hermeneutic methodology and dynamic explanatory power of criminal law doctrine.
作者
魏东
WEI Dong(Law School,Sichuan University,Chengdu 610207)
出处
《现代法学》
CSSCI
北大核心
2021年第5期3-23,共21页
Modern Law Science
基金
四川大学法学院“双一流”建设一流学术成果培育项目资助课题“刑法解释学研究的创新发展方向”(sculaw20210101)。
关键词
刑法解释学
功能主义
司法公正相对主义
整全论
同质互补关系论
Criminal Law Hermeneutics
functionalism
judicial justice relativism
integration theory
homogeneous complementary relationship theory
