摘要
专业法官会议制度是当前司法改革探索出的新模式,目的在于通过发挥法官的主体作用,实现为员额法官提供咨询、发挥案件监督管理和统一裁判尺度的功能。专业法官会议制度在客观上发挥了减轻审判委员会工作压力的作用,但由于司法实践中长期形成的行政化管理惯性、程序正义未获重视、法官案件审理压力大等因素的影响,专业法官会议制度运行出现了重个案讨论轻类案研判、重实体结论轻程序正义、重行政化轻自治性等问题。通过丰富实践功能、强化程序价值、弱化行政色彩,可以推动专业法官会议制度目的的真正实现。
The meeting system of professional judges is a new model explored with the current judicial reform.It aims to provide consultation for specific number of judges,supervise and manage cases and unify the scale of judgment by giving full play to the main role of judges.The meeting system objectively reduces the judicial committee’s stress,but due to the problems like administration management inertia,less attention paid to procedural justice and trial pressure caused in judicial practice,the judge meeting caused the problems like paying more attention to case discussion over categorized cases discussion and judgement,putting stress on entity conclusion and ignoring procedural justice,focusing more on administration and less on autonomy.By enriching the practical function,strengthening the procedural value and weakening administration,the goals of the meeting system can be realized.
作者
高可
GAO Ke(Shiliang Law School,Changzhou University,Changzhou,Jiangsu 213164)
出处
《淮阴师范学院学报(哲学社会科学版)》
2021年第6期555-559,627,647,共7页
Journal of Huaiyin Teachers College(Social Sciences Edition)
基金
2018年度教育部人文社会科学研究青年基金项目“法官员额制改革实施现状的实证研究”(18YJC820020)。
关键词
专业法官会议
审判委员会
司法公正
程序正义
Meeting System of Professional Judges
The Judicial Committee
Judicial Fairness
Procedural Justice