摘要
[目的/意义]结合科技论文内容与引文信息对多篇论文的新颖性进行综合评估,为代表作评价与人才遴选等提供辅助。[方法/过程]提出一种对多篇科技论文新颖性进行对比评估的方法。该方法建立多篇论文问题—方法矩阵关联模型,计算多篇论文的问题新颖度与方法新颖度,并结合施引文献的引文文本与引用情况,构建多篇科技论文的评述画像用于新颖性对比评估。[结果/结论]以图情领域两名学者为例,将两位学者的多篇论文组合分别编号为D1与D2并对其新颖性进行对比评估,得出D2的问题新颖度优于D1,而D1的方法新颖性略高于D2等结论,验证了所提方法的可行性与合理性。
[Purpose/Significance]This paper uses the content and citation information of scientific and technical articles to evaluate the novelty of multiple articles comprehensively,which can assist in evaluating representative works,selecting talents,and other tasks.[Method/Process]This paper proposed a method to evaluate the novelty of multiple scientific and technical articles.This method established the correlation model of the problem-method matrices of multiple papers,and calculated the problem novelty and the method novelty of these papers.Then combining citation text and citation data,this method constructed the review portraits of multiple papers.[Result/Conclusion]Taking two scholars D1 and D2 in library and information research field as examples,multiple scientific and technological articles of D1 and D2 were selected for evaluation.It concludes that the novelty of research problems of D2 are better than those of D1,while the novelty of research methods of D1 are better than those of D2.The results above verify the feasibility and rationality of the proposed method.
作者
张吉玉
张均胜
乔晓东
Zhang Jiyu;Zhang Junsheng;Qiao Xiaodong(Institute of Scientific and Technical Information of China,Beijing 100038;Key Laboratory of Rich-Media Knowledge Organization and Service of Digital Publishing Content of National Press and Publication Administration,Beijing 100038)
出处
《图书情报工作》
CSSCI
北大核心
2023年第19期68-79,共12页
Library and Information Service
基金
国家重点研发计划项目“颠覆性技术识别理论、方法与专家预判系统”(项目编号:2019YFA0707201)
中国科学技术信息研究所创新研究基金“科技论文原创性与新颖性评估方法研究”(项目编号:MS2022-05)研究成果之一。
关键词
科技论文
新颖性评估
代表作评价
问题—方法矩阵
可视化
scientific and technical article
novelty evaluation
the evaluation of representative works
question-method matrix
visualization
