摘要
【目的】调研高水平科学家担任科技期刊编委的情况,梳理科技期刊的编委会并从科学家角度分析其发挥的重要作用,客观呈现科学家参与科技期刊建设的现状。【方法】通过网络调研高水平科学家数据,梳理我国代表性科技期刊的编委会组成和规模,通过问卷调研和访谈了解科学家参与科技期刊建设的现状。【结果】担任科技期刊编委的高水平科学家数量和比例与期刊质量相关,编委会规模与期刊影响力相关,编委在期刊中发挥的作用与期刊编辑期待较为一致,但在个别方面存在差异。【结论】编委会中高水平科学家数量和比例与科技期刊质量存在相关性,科学家作为编委发挥的作用基本达到编辑的预期,但科学家作为科技期刊编委的贡献仍需要系统和多维度的评价。
[Purposes]This paper aims to investigate the involvement of high-level scientists in the editorial boards of scientific journals,organize the structure of these editorial boards,and analyze the significant role they play from the scientists′perspective.It objectively presents the current state of scientists′participation in the development of scientific journals.[Methods]We investigated the data of high-level scientists through online research,analyzed the composition and size of the editorial boards of the representative scientific journals in China,and explored the current situation of scientists′participation in the construction of scientific journals through questionnaires and interviews.[Findings]The number and proportion of high-level scientists serving as editorial board members of scientific journals are related to the quality of the journals,and the size of the editorial board is related to the influence of the journals.The roles played by editorial board members in journals are more consistent with the expectations of the journal′s editors.However,there are discrepancies in certain aspects.[Conclusions]The number and proportion of high-level scientists in editorial boards are related to the quality of scientific journals.While the role played by scientists as editorial board members basically meets the expectations of editors,the contribution of scientists serving on editorial boards of scientific journals still requires systematic and multidimensional evaluation.
作者
李苑
刘荣
刘凤红
沈哲思
彭希珺
杜杏叶
董文杰
梁永霞
初景利
LI Yuan;LIU Rong;LIU Fenghong;SHEN Zhesi;PENG Xijun;DU Xingye;DONG Wenjie;LIANG Yongxia;CHU Jingli(National Science Library,Chinese Academy of Sciences,33 Beisihuan Xilu,Zhongguancun,Haidian District,Beijing 100190,China;Service Center for Societies of China Association for Science and Technology,86 South Xueyuan Road,Haidian District,Beijing 100081,China;Department of Information Resources Management,School of Economics and Management,University of Chinese Academy of Sciences,33 Beisihuan Xilu,Zhongguancun,Haidian District,Beijing 100190,China)
出处
《中国科技期刊研究》
CSSCI
北大核心
2024年第5期593-599,共7页
Chinese Journal of Scientific and Technical Periodicals
基金
中国科协学会服务中心项目“高水平科学家参与科技期刊治理的研究”(2022XFKJQK06)。
关键词
科技期刊
高水平科学家
编委会
Scientific journal
High-level scientist
Editorial board
