摘要
分析辽宁省2022年的34例医疗损害民事纠纷鉴定与二审案,发现我国该类鉴定存在程序启动不当、公正性与科学性不足、“以鉴代审”现象较严重和监督不充分等问题,因此应强化法院对鉴定启动程序的把控和对鉴定意见的实质审查,保障鉴定意见的中立性与科学性,加强对鉴定的全面监督;而充分利用诉讼前委托鉴定,将会极大提高解决民事医疗纠纷的效率。
By analyzing 34 cases of civil dispute appraisal and second trial of medical damage in Liaoning Province in 2022,it is found that there are some problems in such appraisal in China,such as improper initiation of procedures,lack of impartiality and scienti⁃ficity,serious phenomenon of"using appraisal instead of trial"and insufficient supervision.Therefore,it is necessary to strengthen the court's control over the initiation procedure of appraisal and the substantive examination of appraisal opinions,ensure the neutrality and scientificity of appraisal opinions,and strengthen the overall supervision of appraisal.And making full use of pre-litigation commis⁃sioned appraisal will greatly improve the efficiency of solving civil medical disputes.
作者
王瑞恒
吴固
WANG Ruiheng;WU Gu(Liaoning Normal University,Dalian,Liaoning116000,China)
出处
《医学与法学》
2024年第5期111-114,共4页
Medicine and Jurisprudence
基金
2024年四川医事卫生法治研究中心-中国卫生法学会联合项目“健全统一司法鉴定法治体系研究--司法鉴定管理统一立法的研究”(项目编号:YF24-Y20)的阶段性成果。
关键词
民事医疗纠纷
医疗事故技术鉴定
医疗损害司法鉴定
civil medical dispute
technical appraisal of medical accidents
medical damage appraisal
