China’s current academic evaluation system sees publications in core journals as a basic index to measure the academic qualification and quality of an academic institute,a university or an individual.individuals who ...China’s current academic evaluation system sees publications in core journals as a basic index to measure the academic qualification and quality of an academic institute,a university or an individual.individuals who have more essays published in first-class journals will have bigger opportunities for promotion within the academic system.As a result,those展开更多
In academic evaluation, some composite evaluation indexes, for example, quantity, quality and prestige, have the advantages of a large amount of information and unique results. First, in this paper, two composite eval...In academic evaluation, some composite evaluation indexes, for example, quantity, quality and prestige, have the advantages of a large amount of information and unique results. First, in this paper, two composite evaluation indexes are proposed, i.e., the HR index and the CHR index,where the HR index is based on the evaluation of prestige and quality, and the CHR index is based on the evaluation of prestige, quality and quantity. Second, two methods are proposed for testing the HR and CHR indexes. One is to test the principles, i.e., the self-interpretation degree of the results to the principle, by means of partial least squares regression. The other is the analysis of the evaluation results, including the relationships between the composite index and other bibliometric indicators, such as the order of magnitude and distinction and the data distribution of evaluation value, etc. Empirical studies are also conducted. The CSSCI periodicals of the CNKI Library Information and Document Science are employed to test the proposed HR and CHR indexes. Empirical analyses find that the HR index and the CHR index are good evaluation indicators that have broad application and can be used in many aspects, such as scholar, institutional and subject evaluations.展开更多
Based on the background of the special clean-up action of"Breaking the Five-only",this paper combs the relevant policies of domestic science and education evaluation.Using CiteSpace and VOSviewer scientific ...Based on the background of the special clean-up action of"Breaking the Five-only",this paper combs the relevant policies of domestic science and education evaluation.Using CiteSpace and VOSviewer scientific measurement software,this paper makes a visual analysis on the related domestic research of the"Five-only"and"science and education evaluation",and expounds the frontier hot spots and trends of science and education evaluation research in China.Based on this,this paper summarizes the countermeasures and suggestions on how to"break"the"Five-only"and how to"establish"the"new system of science and education evaluation",in order to provide a reference for the sustainable and healthy development of science and education evaluation in China.展开更多
文摘China’s current academic evaluation system sees publications in core journals as a basic index to measure the academic qualification and quality of an academic institute,a university or an individual.individuals who have more essays published in first-class journals will have bigger opportunities for promotion within the academic system.As a result,those
基金supported by the Humanities and Social Sciences projects of the Ministry of Education(17YJA630125)the Philosophy and Social Science Foundation of Zhejiang Province(17NDJC107YB)。
文摘In academic evaluation, some composite evaluation indexes, for example, quantity, quality and prestige, have the advantages of a large amount of information and unique results. First, in this paper, two composite evaluation indexes are proposed, i.e., the HR index and the CHR index,where the HR index is based on the evaluation of prestige and quality, and the CHR index is based on the evaluation of prestige, quality and quantity. Second, two methods are proposed for testing the HR and CHR indexes. One is to test the principles, i.e., the self-interpretation degree of the results to the principle, by means of partial least squares regression. The other is the analysis of the evaluation results, including the relationships between the composite index and other bibliometric indicators, such as the order of magnitude and distinction and the data distribution of evaluation value, etc. Empirical studies are also conducted. The CSSCI periodicals of the CNKI Library Information and Document Science are employed to test the proposed HR and CHR indexes. Empirical analyses find that the HR index and the CHR index are good evaluation indicators that have broad application and can be used in many aspects, such as scholar, institutional and subject evaluations.
基金This research is supported by the Major Projects of the National Social Science Foundation of China,Research on the construction of science and education evaluation information cloud platform and intelligent service based on big data(Grant No.19ZDA348).
文摘Based on the background of the special clean-up action of"Breaking the Five-only",this paper combs the relevant policies of domestic science and education evaluation.Using CiteSpace and VOSviewer scientific measurement software,this paper makes a visual analysis on the related domestic research of the"Five-only"and"science and education evaluation",and expounds the frontier hot spots and trends of science and education evaluation research in China.Based on this,this paper summarizes the countermeasures and suggestions on how to"break"the"Five-only"and how to"establish"the"new system of science and education evaluation",in order to provide a reference for the sustainable and healthy development of science and education evaluation in China.
